VOIP Fring and SIP on the N95
I tested three 'applications': Fring, TruPhone and Gizmo. Actually I would not call the software from TruPhone and Gizmo applications but installation wizards for their service using the inbuilt SIP.
Fring, I installed it and did some tests. First I tested the Fring TestCall in an rural area over GPRS. Voice quality was acceptable, the testmessage and the playback of my own recording was understandable. However is was difficult if not impossible to identify the caller by the sound of his voice and hear any emotions or voice stresses. Text chatting seems fine. Amazingly T9 works quite well for this. Lovely in the cinema. In urban area, GPRS really has hickups in the sound quality. Using wifi seems just as bad. I could not test UMTS, I am not allowing my provider to attach another 8 months to my overpriced phone contract. I just wait the few months to switch. Besides work and home have excellent wideband wifi connections.
TruPhone and Gizmo were tested on a 'open' network and at home behind the firewall. Gizmo could not cope with the firewall. TruPhone worked flawless behind the firewall. There was nothing much to configure on the provider issued firewall thus... bye Gizmo. The soundquality of both is excellent, of landline quality or better. Ridiculus Orange and Vodaphone exclude SIP support in their simlocked N95's, because 'the sound quality is not garanteed'. Well, SIP over wifi is much better at home than my mobile connection on a rainy day.
Both TruPhone and Gizmo run SIP so they should be able to call each other and other SIP networks as well. This in contradiction to Skype. And Skype puts a load on your own network for routing other peoples calls. Using UMTS or GPRS would let you pay heavily for running Skype in the background. The sound quality is far better than Fring. However I had not yet the opportunity to contact my Maltese connections ;-) Since Malta as an island has a small connection to the mainland it is sometimes heavily loaded. Making it a great way to stress test the communnication.
TruPhone currently offers free landline calls to over 40 countries until end of June. Gizmo offers free landline calles for over 40 countries for active users. Some countries allow also free mobile calls. Gizmo gives you 25 US dollarcent free, TruPhone 2 dollar. Dial-out from SIP is very reasonable comparable with Skype out, some individual difference still exist.
SIP is the new Skype as far as I am concerned. Stil I am wondering wether videocalls can be made using SIP on the N95 and wether or not it would work proper. Anyone?
Comments
Just a comment regarding SIP - it's just a protocol that the other applications use (Session Initiation Protocol), not an application in itself.
As for Skype video calls - it will be very interesting to see...
What I'd like is a desktop stand that allowed me to use the front camera as a webcam..:-)
There is software to use your mobile camera as a webcam available. Have a google.
It's good to use Fring if you have a crippled N95 that doesn't allow TruPhone to work natively. I've found that using TruPhone is generally better than using Fring but if you want to use it without a WiFi connection then Fring is perfect!
Cheers,
Merlz
I use gotalk (au voip company, bad support and crappy website, but have nice features otherwise). The cool thing about gotalk is that they give you a landline number in australia, so people can call you for a local cost to your mobile. Fring works with gotalk (just like any other sip service), but when I get phone calls coming in via fring over gotalk, I can't hear anything and they can't hear anything either. Making sip calls through fring using gotalk is fine can hear everything etc. Also can use SIP in the n95 using gotalk, but only connects if using wireless lan, but doesn't connect via 3G data (Through Planet 3 or 3 net access).
So here are 2 questions:
Does nokia n95 built in SIP support connections through cellular packet data - 3G or does it only work over Wireless LAN?
Has anyone had any issues with fring receiving sip calls and not having any voice coming through or being sent (ie can't hear anything)?
Any suggestions appreciated.
PS the voice quality of fring over HSDPS (3.5G and 3G) is good, also over lan the n95 sip and fring is good quality too. Well worth the cost.
Cheers Roman
Yes the N95's native sip-stack can VoIP over 3G. I can on my t-mobile connection. Not without an occasional interuptions since it is very low bandwidth.
Trouble with incoming SIP connections on wifi networks are in my experience caused by improper firewall configuration. Portforwarding of port 5060 udp to you phones wifi ip-number is in general required.
Fring in general rerouts SIP over their own node and as such has no problems traversing firewalls. As such voice quality howerver is less than pure SIP, the extra node distances cause more packet-'loss'. IF you are using fring over 3G they might be causing the problems.
My SIP number is also a fixed landline number for almost no cost (10 euros a year). Many VoIP companies now provide this feature, but mostly they are far more expensive.
I have the SIP-connection running 24hrs a day, the battery drain is insignificant.